What Manganese Is

Manganese is an essential trace mineral element required by the human body in very small amounts but critical for numerous physiological functions. The adult human body contains approximately 10-20 mg of total manganese, distributed throughout various tissues with the highest concentrations in bones, liver, pancreas, kidneys, and brain. Manganese is named after the Greek word for magic, "magnes," reflecting early confusion between manganese-containing minerals and magnetic compounds. The mineral exists in multiple oxidation states in biological systems, with Mn²⁺ (manganous) and Mn³⁺ (manganic) being the most common forms. Manganese functions primarily as a cofactor for numerous enzymes (called metalloenzymes) involved in metabolism, antioxidant defense, bone formation, and wound healing. Unlike some minerals where the body tightly regulates absorption to maintain balance, manganese homeostasis is achieved mainly through regulation of excretion via bile, with the body absorbing only 1-5% of dietary manganese and eliminating excess through feces. Manganese deficiency is rare in humans, while toxicity from excessive supplementation or occupational/environmental exposure is a more significant concern. Your body cannot produce manganese, so it must be obtained through diet or supplementation.

Functions and Uses in the Body

Manganese serves numerous critical functions throughout the body, acting as a cofactor for many essential enzymes. One of manganese's most important roles is in antioxidant defense through manganese superoxide dismutase (MnSOD), a critical antioxidant enzyme located in mitochondria. MnSOD protects cells from oxidative damage by neutralizing superoxide radicals, which are highly reactive oxygen species produced during normal cellular metabolism. Without adequate manganese, MnSOD activity is impaired, leading to increased oxidative stress and cellular damage. This makes manganese essential for protecting mitochondria and cells from free radical damage.

Manganese is crucial for bone formation and maintenance. It's a cofactor for enzymes involved in bone matrix formation, including enzymes that synthesize proteoglycans (components of cartilage and bone matrix) and enzymes involved in collagen synthesis. Manganese activates enzymes necessary for bone mineralization and remodeling. Deficiency, while rare, can impair skeletal development and bone density.

The mineral plays important roles in carbohydrate metabolism and glucose regulation. Manganese is a cofactor for pyruvate carboxylase, an enzyme involved in gluconeogenesis (production of glucose from non-carbohydrate sources). It's also involved in glycolysis and the citric acid cycle (energy production pathways). Adequate manganese supports normal glucose metabolism and may influence insulin secretion and action.

Manganese is essential for amino acid, protein, and cholesterol metabolism. It's a cofactor for arginase, which is involved in the urea cycle for processing amino acids and eliminating nitrogen waste. Manganese-dependent enzymes also participate in cholesterol synthesis and metabolism, potentially influencing blood lipid levels.

The mineral is necessary for wound healing and collagen formation. Manganese activates prolidase, an enzyme required for collagen production and wound repair. It's involved in the synthesis of proline, an amino acid that's a major component of collagen. Adequate manganese supports skin integrity, wound healing, and connective tissue health.

Manganese influences brain function and neurotransmitter metabolism. It's involved in the synthesis and metabolism of neurotransmitters including glutamine, glutamate, and GABA. Manganese-dependent enzymes are involved in the metabolism of dopamine and serotonin. The mineral is concentrated in certain brain regions and may influence mood, cognition, and neurological function, though the relationship is complex—both deficiency and excess can impair brain function.

The mineral plays a role in immune function, supporting the activity of immune cells and potentially influencing inflammatory responses. Manganese-dependent enzymes are involved in immune cell metabolism and function.

Manganese is involved in reproductive function. It's necessary for normal reproductive hormone synthesis and function, and adequate manganese supports fertility in both sexes.

The mineral may influence blood clotting through its role in various coagulation processes, though the mechanisms aren't fully elucidated.

Manganese is involved in fat metabolism, with manganese-dependent enzymes participating in fatty acid synthesis and metabolism.

Benefits of Adequate Manganese Intake

Maintaining optimal manganese levels provides several health benefits, though it's important to note that deficiency is rare in humans eating varied diets. For antioxidant protection, adequate manganese enables manganese superoxide dismutase (MnSOD) function, helping protect cells from oxidative damage and free radicals, reduce oxidative stress in mitochondria, support healthy aging at the cellular level, protect tissues and organs from oxidative injury, and potentially reduce the risk of diseases associated with oxidative stress.

In terms of bone and skeletal health, sufficient manganese supports bone formation and mineralization, contributes to maintaining bone mineral density, helps maintain cartilage integrity, supports healthy skeletal development in children, may reduce the risk of osteoporosis when combined with other bone-supporting nutrients, and supports connective tissue health.

For metabolic health, adequate manganese supports normal glucose metabolism, may help maintain healthy blood sugar levels, supports efficient carbohydrate metabolism, enables proper energy production from food, and may support healthy cholesterol metabolism.

Manganese provides benefits for wound healing and skin health including supporting collagen synthesis for wound repair, promoting faster healing of injuries, maintaining skin integrity and elasticity, supporting connective tissue repair, and potentially reducing scar formation.

The mineral may support cognitive and neurological function through involvement in neurotransmitter synthesis and metabolism, support for brain health and function, potential influence on mood regulation, support for normal neurological development, and protection of brain cells from oxidative damage.

For reproductive health, adequate manganese supports normal reproductive function in both sexes, may support fertility, is involved in sex hormone metabolism, and supports healthy reproductive system development.

Additional potential benefits include supporting immune system function, potentially reducing inflammation, supporting joint health and cartilage function, contributing to healthy hair and nail growth, and supporting overall metabolic efficiency.

Potential Negatives and Risks

While manganese is essential, excessive intake—particularly from supplements or environmental/occupational exposure—can cause serious problems. The primary concern with manganese is neurotoxicity from chronic excessive exposure. Unlike most essential minerals where deficiency is the main concern, with manganese, toxicity is often more problematic than deficiency.

Manganese Toxicity (Manganism) is a neurological disorder resembling Parkinson's disease that results from chronic excessive manganese exposure. It primarily occurs from occupational inhalation of manganese dust or fumes (welding, mining, battery manufacturing) but can also result from excessive oral intake, though this is less common and requires very high doses over extended periods.

Symptoms of manganism include tremors (particularly in hands), muscle rigidity and stiffness, difficulty with fine motor movements, balance problems and gait disturbances, bradykinesia (slowed movement), dystonia (involuntary muscle contractions), mask-like facial expression, cognitive impairment and memory problems, mood changes (depression, irritability, aggression), speech difficulties, and hallucinations or psychosis in severe cases. Unlike Parkinson's disease, manganism often presents with psychiatric symptoms early and responds poorly to levodopa (Parkinson's medication).

Brain Accumulation is particularly concerning. Manganese accumulates in the basal ganglia (brain regions controlling movement) and can cause permanent neurological damage. MRI scans show characteristic bright signals in these regions with manganese accumulation. Early-stage toxicity may be reversible if exposure is stopped, but advanced manganism causes irreversible brain damage.

Liver Disease Concerns exist because the liver is the primary organ for manganese excretion through bile. People with liver disease (cirrhosis, hepatitis) have impaired manganese excretion and are at much higher risk for manganese accumulation and neurotoxicity even at normal intake levels. These individuals should avoid manganese supplements.

Infants and Children are more susceptible to manganese neurotoxicity because the blood-brain barrier is not fully developed, allowing more manganese to enter the brain, and developing brains are more vulnerable to toxicity. Excessive manganese exposure in infants and children can impair cognitive development, reduce IQ, cause attention and learning problems, and affect behavior.

Iron-Manganese Interaction is important. Iron deficiency increases manganese absorption and may increase the risk of manganese toxicity. Conversely, high manganese can interfere with iron absorption and contribute to anemia. The balance between these minerals is important.

Reproductive Effects have been observed with excessive manganese exposure in animal studies, including reduced fertility and effects on reproductive hormone levels, though human data is limited.

Gastrointestinal Effects from high-dose manganese supplements include nausea and vomiting, abdominal pain, diarrhea, loss of appetite, and general digestive upset.

Respiratory Effects from inhaling manganese dust or fumes (occupational exposure) include respiratory irritation, chronic bronchitis, pneumonitis (lung inflammation), and potential lung damage.

Environmental and Water Contamination can occur in some areas where drinking water contains excessive manganese (from natural geological sources or industrial contamination). Chronic exposure to high-manganese water has been associated with cognitive and behavioral problems in children.

Medication Interactions can occur. Some antipsychotic medications can increase manganese levels in the brain, potentially increasing neurotoxicity risk when combined with high manganese intake.

Recommended Intake and Serving Sizes

Adequate Intake (AI) Levels: Manganese has Adequate Intake (AI) levels rather than RDAs because there isn't sufficient evidence to establish precise requirements. The AI represents estimated adequate intake based on typical intake in healthy populations:

  • Adult men aged 19+: 2.3 mg per day

  • Adult women aged 19+: 1.8 mg per day

  • Pregnant women: 2.0 mg per day

  • Breastfeeding women: 2.6 mg per day

  • Adolescents aged 14-18: 1.6-2.2 mg per day (females lower, males higher)

  • Children aged 9-13: 1.9 mg (boys), 1.6 mg (girls) per day

  • Children aged 4-8: 1.5 mg per day

  • Children aged 1-3: 1.2 mg per day

  • Infants aged 7-12 months: 0.6 mg per day

  • Infants aged 0-6 months: 0.003 mg per day

Tolerable Upper Intake Level (UL):

  • Adults: 11 mg per day

  • Adolescents aged 14-18: 9 mg per day

  • Children aged 9-13: 6 mg per day

  • Children aged 4-8: 3 mg per day

  • Children aged 1-3: 2 mg per day

These upper limits apply to total manganese from food, water, and supplements. However, the primary toxicity concern is from occupational inhalation, not dietary intake in most cases.

Typical Dietary Intake: Average manganese intake in Western populations ranges from 1-5 mg per day for adults, suggesting most people meet the AI through diet alone. However, intake varies widely based on food choices, with plant-based diets typically providing more manganese than diets heavy in animal products.

Important Context: The AI for manganese is based on preventing deficiency (which is rare) rather than optimizing all manganese-dependent functions. Some researchers suggest optimal intake may be toward the higher end of typical dietary intake (3-5 mg daily), but this remains under investigation. Unlike many nutrients where more is often better up to a point, with manganese, staying within the AI range and avoiding excessive supplementation is prudent due to neurotoxicity concerns.

Special Considerations:

Infants: Formula-fed infants may receive different manganese amounts than breastfed infants. Soy-based formulas are particularly high in manganese, raising concerns about potential excessive exposure in formula-fed infants. Breast milk is relatively low in manganese, and exclusively breastfed infants receive adequate amounts despite the low concentration.

People with Liver Disease: Should be particularly cautious about manganese intake and avoid supplements, as impaired bile excretion can lead to accumulation.

What to Take With Manganese

Copper and Zinc work alongside manganese in antioxidant defense. Copper-zinc superoxide dismutase (CuZnSOD) complements manganese superoxide dismutase (MnSOD), providing antioxidant protection in different cellular compartments. Balanced intake of all three minerals supports comprehensive antioxidant defense.

Calcium works with manganese for bone health. Both minerals are involved in bone formation and mineralization. Adequate calcium alongside manganese supports optimal skeletal health.

Vitamin D supports calcium metabolism and bone health, working synergistically with manganese for skeletal health.

Vitamin K is important for bone health and works alongside manganese in bone metabolism. Both nutrients support proper bone formation and mineralization.

Magnesium is involved in bone health and numerous metabolic processes that overlap with manganese functions. Both minerals support skeletal health and metabolic function.

Chondroitin and Glucosamine are sometimes combined with manganese in joint health supplements, based on manganese's role in cartilage formation. Some research suggests this combination may benefit osteoarthritis, though evidence is mixed.

Other Trace Minerals including selenium, chromium, and molybdenum work in concert with manganese in various metabolic processes. Balanced trace mineral intake supports overall health.

What NOT to Take With Manganese

High-Dose Iron Supplements can interfere with manganese absorption, as both minerals compete for the same absorption mechanisms in the intestines. Conversely, manganese can interfere with iron absorption. If taking therapeutic iron doses (over 45 mg), separate from manganese supplements by 2-3 hours. This interaction is one reason why people with iron deficiency may have increased manganese absorption.

High-Dose Calcium Supplements (over 1,000 mg at once) may compete with manganese for absorption, though this interaction is not as well-established as the iron interaction. Moderate calcium intake from food doesn't significantly affect manganese status.

Magnesium Supplements in very high doses might theoretically compete with manganese for absorption, though this is not well-documented. Normal magnesium supplementation doesn't appear problematic.

Zinc Supplements in high doses (over 50 mg) may compete with manganese for absorption. If taking therapeutic zinc, consider separating from manganese supplements.

Antacids containing aluminum, calcium, or magnesium may reduce manganese absorption by altering stomach pH or through direct binding.

Fiber Supplements in very high doses, particularly phytate-containing supplements, may reduce manganese absorption, though dietary fiber from food doesn't typically cause manganese deficiency.

Certain Medications can affect manganese levels. Some antipsychotic medications (particularly those causing extrapyramidal side effects) may increase brain manganese levels, making it particularly important to avoid manganese supplements while on these medications.

Antacids and Laxatives containing magnesium may affect manganese absorption or excretion.

Who Should Take Manganese Supplements

Manganese deficiency is extremely rare in humans eating varied diets, so manganese supplementation is seldom necessary. Most people get adequate manganese from food. However, certain individuals might consider manganese supplementation:

People with documented manganese deficiency (extremely rare) would need supplementation. True deficiency is almost never seen in free-living populations eating normal diets but has been reported in people on long-term total parenteral nutrition (TPN) without adequate manganese, individuals with certain rare genetic disorders affecting manganese metabolism, and people with severe malnutrition or highly restricted diets.

Individuals with osteoporosis or low bone density are sometimes advised to take manganese as part of comprehensive bone health supplementation (combined with calcium, vitamin D, magnesium, zinc, and copper). Some research suggests manganese may support bone mineral density, though evidence is not conclusive. Doses used in bone health research are typically 2-5 mg daily.

People with osteoarthritis may consider manganese supplementation, as some research suggests manganese (particularly as manganese ascorbate or combined with glucosamine and chondroitin) may reduce joint pain and improve function. However, evidence is limited and inconsistent. Typical doses in arthritis research are 3-40 mg daily, with higher doses raising toxicity concerns.

Those with seizure disorders have been studied for potential manganese supplementation benefits, as some research suggests manganese deficiency may contribute to seizure susceptibility. However, this should only be pursued under medical supervision, as the relationship is complex.

People on long-term total parenteral nutrition (TPN) or tube feeding require adequate manganese in their formula to prevent deficiency. This is managed in medical settings.

Athletes have occasionally been suggested to benefit from manganese supplementation for bone health and antioxidant support, but evidence is lacking and dietary intake is typically adequate.

Vegetarians and vegans typically get adequate or even high manganese intake from plant-based diets (grains, legumes, nuts, seeds, leafy greens are all good sources), so supplementation is rarely needed. Plant-based diets generally provide more manganese than omnivorous diets.

Important Note: Even in populations that might benefit from manganese, supplementation should be modest (staying within the AI and well below the UL) and ideally part of a comprehensive multivitamin/mineral rather than high-dose standalone manganese supplementation. The neurotoxicity risk from excessive manganese makes conservative supplementation essential.

Who Should Avoid or Be Cautious With Manganese Supplements

People with liver disease (cirrhosis, hepatitis, liver failure) should absolutely avoid manganese supplements and may need to limit dietary manganese. The liver excretes manganese through bile, and impaired liver function leads to manganese accumulation in the brain, significantly increasing neurotoxicity risk. Even normal dietary amounts may be problematic in advanced liver disease.

Individuals with neurological disorders including Parkinson's disease, Parkinsonian syndromes, movement disorders, or any unexplained neurological symptoms should avoid manganese supplements unless under medical supervision. Manganese can worsen these conditions or complicate diagnosis.

Those with a history of psychiatric disorders should be cautious with manganese, as excess manganese can cause or exacerbate psychiatric symptoms including depression, anxiety, hallucinations, and aggressive behavior.

Infants and young children should not receive manganese supplements beyond what's in age-appropriate formulas or multivitamins. Their developing brains are particularly vulnerable to manganese neurotoxicity. Parents should be aware that soy-based infant formulas are naturally high in manganese, and while they're generally considered safe, some concern exists about excessive exposure.

Pregnant women should not exceed the AI for manganese (2.0 mg) without medical supervision. While adequate manganese is necessary for pregnancy, excessive amounts could potentially affect fetal development.

People with iron deficiency are at increased risk for manganese absorption and potential toxicity because iron deficiency enhances manganese uptake. These individuals should correct iron deficiency and avoid manganese supplements.

Those taking antipsychotic medications (particularly haloperidol and similar drugs) should avoid manganese supplements, as some of these medications can increase manganese levels in the brain and increase neurotoxicity risk.

Welders, miners, and battery workers who have occupational manganese exposure should definitely avoid manganese supplements, as they're already at risk for excessive exposure through inhalation.

People living in areas with high manganese in drinking water should avoid supplements and may need to use alternative water sources or filtration systems.

Men and non-menstruating women without specific conditions requiring manganese often don't need supplementation, as dietary intake is typically adequate.

Anyone experiencing symptoms suggestive of manganese toxicity (tremors, movement problems, mood changes) should avoid manganese and seek medical evaluation.

Those taking multiple supplements should check total manganese content from all sources to ensure they're not exceeding the UL.

Deficiency Symptoms

Manganese deficiency is extremely rare in humans and has only been reported in a few cases, primarily in people receiving manganese-free total parenteral nutrition or consuming experimental manganese-depleted diets in research settings. When deficiency does occur, potential symptoms include:

Skeletal Abnormalities:

  • Impaired bone growth and development

  • Reduced bone mineral density

  • Skeletal malformations in severe cases

  • Joint pain and stiffness

  • Increased fracture risk

Metabolic Effects:

  • Impaired glucose tolerance

  • Altered carbohydrate metabolism

  • Changes in cholesterol levels

  • Impaired fat metabolism

Skin and Hair Changes:

  • Skin rash or dermatitis

  • Changes in hair color or texture

  • Slow wound healing

  • Poor nail growth

Reproductive Issues:

  • Impaired fertility in animal studies

  • Reduced reproductive function

  • Potential effects on offspring development (in animal studies)

Growth and Development:

  • Slowed growth rate in children

  • Developmental delays

  • Impaired skeletal maturation

Neurological Symptoms:

  • Mood changes

  • Potential seizure susceptibility in severe cases

  • Ataxia (loss of coordination)

  • Hearing problems (in animal studies)

Other Symptoms:

  • Weakness and fatigue

  • Nausea

  • Changes in blood clotting

Why Deficiency is So Rare: Manganese is widely available in plant-based foods including whole grains, legumes, nuts, seeds, leafy greens, and tea. Even modest intake of these foods provides adequate manganese. The body also absorbs manganese very inefficiently (1-5%), which protects against toxicity but also means dietary intake doesn't need to be very high. Additionally, the body regulates manganese by adjusting excretion rather than absorption, providing another mechanism to maintain adequate status.

Documented Deficiency Cases: The few documented human cases of manganese deficiency have occurred in very specific circumstances: controlled research settings with manganese-depleted experimental diets, long-term total parenteral nutrition without adequate manganese supplementation, and extremely restricted diets lacking plant foods (theoretical). Even in these cases, symptoms were often subtle or inconsistent.

Populations Theoretically at Risk: While deficiency is rare, the following groups might theoretically be at slightly higher risk, though clinical deficiency still rarely occurs: people with severe malabsorption disorders (particularly those affecting the small intestine), those on long-term TPN without adequate trace minerals, individuals with certain rare genetic disorders affecting manganese metabolism, and people on extremely restricted diets avoiding all plant foods (unlikely).

Toxicity Symptoms

Manganese toxicity is of much greater concern than deficiency. Toxicity primarily occurs from occupational inhalation of manganese dust or fumes, but can also result from excessive oral intake from supplements or contaminated water.

Manganism (Manganese-Induced Parkinsonism): The primary manifestation of chronic manganese toxicity is a neurological disorder resembling Parkinson's disease but with distinct features:

Motor Symptoms:

  • Fine tremor (particularly hands)

  • Bradykinesia (slow movement)

  • Muscle rigidity and stiffness

  • Difficulty with balance and coordination

  • Gait disturbances (walking problems)

  • Dystonia (involuntary muscle contractions)

  • Mask-like facial expression

  • Difficulty with fine motor tasks

  • Postural instability

Psychiatric and Cognitive Symptoms:

  • Irritability and aggressive behavior

  • Depression

  • Anxiety

  • Hallucinations

  • Psychosis

  • Memory problems

  • Difficulty concentrating

  • Reduced cognitive function

  • Mood swings

  • Apathy

Early Symptoms (Prodromal Phase):

  • Subtle personality changes

  • Mild cognitive impairment

  • Emotional lability

  • Sleep disturbances

  • Headache

  • Muscle cramps or pain

  • General weakness

Progression: Early-stage manganism may be reversible if exposure is stopped. Continued exposure leads to progressive, irreversible neurological damage. Advanced manganism causes permanent disability with severe movement problems, significant cognitive impairment, and psychiatric disturbances.

Differences from Parkinson's Disease:

  • Manganism often presents with psychiatric symptoms before motor symptoms

  • Bilateral (both sides) symptom presentation is more common

  • Young age of onset (occupational exposure can occur at any age)

  • Poor response to levodopa (Parkinson's medication)

  • MRI shows characteristic signal changes in basal ganglia

  • Dystonia is more prominent than in Parkinson's

Other Toxicity Effects:

Respiratory Effects (Inhalation Exposure):

  • Chronic bronchitis

  • Pneumonitis

  • Metal fume fever

  • Respiratory irritation

  • Reduced lung function

Gastrointestinal Effects (High Oral Doses):

  • Nausea and vomiting

  • Abdominal pain

  • Diarrhea

  • Loss of appetite

Hepatic Effects:

  • Elevated liver enzymes (though liver itself is not typically damaged by manganese; rather, liver disease impairs manganese excretion)

Reproductive and Developmental:

  • Potential effects on male fertility (animal studies)

  • Developmental effects in children exposed to high levels

Cognitive Effects in Children: Children exposed to high environmental manganese (particularly from contaminated water or living near manganese emission sources) show reduced IQ, attention problems and hyperactivity, learning difficulties, memory problems, and behavioral issues. These effects can occur at exposure levels lower than those causing manganism in adults.

Toxic Exposure Levels:

Inhalation (Occupational):

  • Chronic exposure to air concentrations over 1-5 mg/m³ increases risk

  • Welder's exposure can be 5-100+ mg/m³

  • Duration and cumulative dose determine risk

Oral Intake:

  • Upper limit: 11 mg/day for adults

  • Toxicity from oral intake alone is rare but possible with very high chronic supplementation (over 15-20 mg daily for extended periods)

  • Contaminated drinking water with >0.4 mg/L manganese has been associated with cognitive effects in children

Risk Factors for Toxicity:

  • Occupational exposure (welding, mining, battery manufacturing)

  • Impaired liver function (drastically increases risk)

  • Iron deficiency (increases manganese absorption)

  • Young age (children more vulnerable)

  • Contaminated drinking water

  • Excessive supplementation

  • Genetic susceptibility (may vary)

Diagnosis: Blood manganese levels are not reliable indicators of toxicity, as the body tightly regulates blood levels. MRI showing characteristic changes in basal ganglia, neurological examination revealing Parkinsonian features, exposure history (occupational or environmental), and symptoms consistent with manganism help establish diagnosis.

Treatment: Eliminate exposure immediately. Chelation therapy has limited effectiveness for manganism. Symptomatic treatment for movement and psychiatric symptoms. Physical therapy and rehabilitation. Prognosis depends on severity and duration of exposure—early stage may improve with exposure elimination; advanced stage typically causes permanent disability.

Timing: When to Take Manganese

Since manganese supplementation is rarely necessary for most people, timing is primarily relevant for those taking manganese in multivitamins or for specific health conditions:

Once Daily (Most Common): Manganese supplements or multivitamins containing manganese are typically taken once daily, as manganese is stored in the body and doesn't require multiple daily doses for maintaining levels.

With or Without Food: Manganese can be taken with or without food. Absorption is not dramatically affected by food, though some studies suggest absorption may be slightly better on an empty stomach. However, taking with food may reduce potential stomach upset and is more convenient for most people.

Morning or Evening: There's no specific advantage to morning versus evening dosing. Choose whichever time you'll remember consistently and that fits with your routine.

With Other Minerals: Manganese is often included in bone health formulas with calcium, magnesium, zinc, copper, and vitamin D. These can all be taken together, though very high doses of iron or zinc might affect manganese absorption. For most people taking standard multivitamins or bone formulas, this isn't a concern.

Consistency: Taking manganese-containing supplements at the same time each day helps maintain steady levels and makes it easier to remember.

Important Note: Given the neurotoxicity concerns with manganese, there's no need to optimize timing to increase absorption—in fact, the opposite is true. The goal is adequate intake, not maximizing absorption. Taking with food is perfectly fine and may even be preferable.

Food vs. Empty Stomach

Either Is Generally Acceptable: Manganese supplements can be taken with or without food with minimal difference in practical terms.

With Food: Taking manganese with meals is convenient and comfortable, reduces any potential stomach upset, and is easier to integrate into daily routine. Some components of food (fiber, phytates, calcium) may slightly reduce absorption, but this is generally not a concern given that we want adequate, not excessive, absorption.

Empty Stomach: Some research suggests manganese absorption may be slightly better on an empty stomach (perhaps 5-10% better), though the difference is not dramatic. Taking on empty stomach is fine if that's more convenient and you experience no stomach upset.

Practical Recommendation: For most people taking manganese in a multivitamin or bone health supplement, taking with breakfast or another meal is the simplest and most convenient approach. There's no compelling reason to take on an empty stomach, and the slightly reduced absorption from food is not problematic—in fact, it may be beneficial given toxicity concerns.

With Adequate Fluids: Regardless of timing, take manganese supplements with a full glass of water to ensure proper dissolution and swallowing.

Types of Manganese Supplements and Forms

Several forms of manganese are available in dietary supplements:

Manganese Sulfate:

  • Common Form: Often used in generic supplements

  • Elemental Manganese: About 36% by weight

  • Absorption: Moderate

  • Uses: General supplementation

  • Cost: Inexpensive

  • Notes: Well-studied form

Manganese Gluconate:

  • Common Form: Widely used in supplements

  • Elemental Manganese: About 11% by weight

  • Absorption: Good

  • Uses: General supplementation, often in multivitamins

  • Cost: Moderate

  • Notes: Well-tolerated

Manganese Citrate:

  • Elemental Manganese: Variable

  • Absorption: Good

  • Uses: General supplementation

  • Cost: Moderate

  • Notes: Citrate form is generally well-absorbed

Manganese Chloride:

  • Form: Inorganic salt

  • Absorption: Moderate

  • Uses: Sometimes used in supplements

  • Notes: Less common than other forms

Manganese Amino Acid Chelate:

  • Form: Manganese bound to amino acids

  • Absorption: Generally good to excellent

  • Uses: High-quality supplements

  • Cost: More expensive

  • Notes: Chelated forms are marketed as better absorbed, though the practical significance is debated

Manganese Glycinate (Bisglycinate):

  • Form: Manganese chelated to glycine

  • Absorption: Excellent

  • Tolerability: Very good

  • Uses: Premium supplements

  • Cost: More expensive

  • Notes: Gentle on stomach, well-absorbed

Manganese Ascorbate (Vitamin C Manganese Complex):

  • Form: Manganese bound to ascorbic acid

  • Uses: Sometimes used in arthritis supplements

  • Notes: Some research on joint health used this form

  • Cost: More expensive

Manganese in Combination Products:

Multivitamins: Most multivitamins contain 2-5 mg manganese (typically as manganese gluconate or sulfate). This is appropriate for general supplementation in people without contraindications.

Bone Health Formulas: Often combine manganese (2-5 mg) with calcium, magnesium, vitamin D, zinc, copper, and sometimes boron for comprehensive skeletal support.

Joint Health Supplements: Some products combine manganese with glucosamine, chondroitin, MSM, and other joint-supporting compounds.

Antioxidant Formulas: May include manganese along with other antioxidant nutrients (vitamins C, E, selenium, zinc, copper).

Dosage Forms: Manganese supplements come as tablets, capsules, liquids, and powders. The form doesn't significantly affect efficacy; choose based on personal preference.

Choosing a Form: For most people who need supplementation, the form matters less than the dose. Manganese gluconate, citrate, or amino acid chelates in a comprehensive multivitamin or bone formula (providing 2-5 mg) are appropriate. Avoid high-dose standalone manganese supplements (over 5 mg) unless specifically prescribed for a documented deficiency or condition. Given neurotoxicity concerns, there's no advantage to maximizing absorption with premium forms—adequate absorption from standard forms is sufficient.

Quality Considerations: Choose reputable brands with third-party testing (USP, NSF, ConsumerLab) for purity and accurate dosing. Check total manganese content from all supplements to avoid exceeding the UL (11 mg). Be aware of manganese content in drinking water if you live in an area with naturally high levels or contamination.

Food Sources of Manganese

Manganese is widely available in plant-based foods, making dietary deficiency extremely rare:

Excellent Manganese Sources (>2 mg per serving):

  • Whole wheat flour (1 cup): 3.8 mg

  • Pineapple (1 cup, chunks): 2.6 mg

  • Pineapple juice (1 cup): 1.3 mg

  • Pecans (1 oz): 1.3 mg

  • Oats, dry (1 cup): 3.8 mg

  • Brown rice, cooked (1 cup): 2.1 mg

  • Tea, brewed (1 cup): 0.4-1.3 mg (varies by type and brewing)

  • Hazelnuts (1 oz): 1.7 mg

  • Spinach, cooked (1 cup): 1.7 mg

Very Good Manganese Sources (1-2 mg per serving):

  • Peanuts (1 oz): 0.6 mg

  • Almonds (1 oz): 0.6 mg

  • Chickpeas, cooked (1 cup): 1.7 mg

  • Lima beans, cooked (1 cup): 1.0 mg

  • Navy beans, cooked (1 cup): 1.1 mg

  • Sweet potato, baked (1 medium): 0.8 mg

  • Whole wheat bread (2 slices): 1.1 mg

  • Quinoa, cooked (1 cup): 1.2 mg

Good Manganese Sources (0.5-1 mg per serving):

  • Walnuts (1 oz): 0.9 mg

  • Tofu (1/2 cup): 0.9 mg

  • Tempeh (1/2 cup): 1.1 mg

  • Lentils, cooked (1 cup): 1.0 mg

  • Raspberries (1 cup): 0.8 mg

  • Strawberries (1 cup): 0.6 mg

  • Blackberries (1 cup): 0.9 mg

  • Kale, cooked (1 cup): 0.5 mg

  • Chard, cooked (1 cup): 0.6 mg

  • Green beans (1 cup): 0.4 mg

  • Beets (1 cup): 0.7 mg

Moderate Manganese Sources (0.1-0.5 mg per serving):

  • Carrots (1 cup): 0.4 mg

  • Broccoli (1 cup): 0.3 mg

  • Cabbage (1 cup): 0.2 mg

  • Tomatoes (1 medium): 0.1 mg

  • Potatoes (1 medium): 0.4 mg

  • Banana (1 medium): 0.3 mg

  • Orange (1 medium): 0.1 mg

Foods Low in Manganese:

  • Most meats and poultry (<0.1 mg per serving)

  • Most fish and seafood (<0.1 mg per serving)

  • Eggs (<0.05 mg per egg)

  • Dairy products (<0.05 mg per serving)

  • Refined grains (white bread, white rice—manganese is removed in refining)

Tea as a Manganese Source: Tea is a particularly rich source of manganese, with both black and green tea providing significant amounts. A single cup can provide 0.4-1.3 mg or more, depending on variety and brewing time. Regular tea drinkers can get substantial manganese from this source. However, excessive tea consumption (>8-10 cups daily) could theoretically contribute to excessive manganese intake, particularly if combined with supplements.

Dietary Patterns and Manganese:

Plant-Based Diets: Vegetarian and vegan diets are typically high in manganese due to emphasis on whole grains, legumes, nuts, seeds, and vegetables. These populations rarely need manganese supplementation.

Omnivorous Diets: Provide adequate manganese when they include whole grains, nuts, fruits, and vegetables. Heavily animal-based diets with minimal plant foods might provide less manganese, though deficiency is still extremely rare.

Refined Food Diets: Diets heavy in refined grains, processed foods, and limited fruits/vegetables provide less manganese than whole food diets, but still typically meet the AI.

Bioavailability: Only 1-5% of dietary manganese is absorbed, with the rest excreted in feces. Absorption is influenced by manganese needs (absorption increases slightly when status is low), iron status (iron deficiency increases manganese absorption), and presence of other minerals (calcium, phosphorus, fiber may slightly reduce absorption). However, the body's primary regulation of manganese status is through controlling excretion via bile rather than absorption.

Meeting Daily Needs: Meeting the AI for manganese (2.3 mg for men, 1.8 mg for women) is easily accomplished with a varied diet including whole grains, nuts, legumes, fruits, and vegetables. One cup of cooked oatmeal for breakfast provides most of the daily manganese need. A handful of nuts as a snack provides 30-50% of daily needs. A cup of tea provides 20-70% of daily needs.

Important Considerations

Toxicity is a Greater Concern Than Deficiency: Unlike most essential nutrients where deficiency is the primary concern, with manganese, excessive intake causing neurotoxicity is more worrisome than deficiency. This unique situation makes conservative supplementation important.

The Liver Connection: The liver is critical for manganese homeostasis, as it excretes manganese through bile. Any degree of liver disease (cirrhosis, hepatitis, fatty liver disease) impairs this process and dramatically increases the risk of manganese accumulation and neurotoxicity. People with liver disease should avoid manganese supplements entirely.

Occupational Exposure Concerns: Welders are at particularly high risk for manganese toxicity due to inhaling manganese fumes from welding rods. "Welder's disease" or "welder's Parkinsonism" is a recognized occupational hazard. Other at-risk occupations include mining, battery manufacturing, dry cell battery production, steel production, and ferroalloy production.

Water Contamination Issues: Some areas have naturally high manganese in groundwater due to geological conditions. In other areas, industrial contamination may elevate manganese levels. Drinking water standards exist (EPA secondary standard: 0.05 mg/L for aesthetic reasons; some suggest health-based levels should be lower), but enforcement varies. Areas with manganese levels exceeding 0.3-0.4 mg/L have been associated with cognitive and behavioral effects in children.

Iron-Manganese Balance: Iron and manganese compete for absorption. Iron deficiency increases manganese absorption, potentially increasing toxicity risk if manganese intake is high. This is one reason why iron-deficient individuals should avoid manganese supplements. Conversely, high manganese can interfere with iron absorption and contribute to anemia.

Soy Formula Concerns: Soy-based infant formulas naturally contain 10-80 times more manganese than breast milk or cow's milk-based formulas due to manganese in soybeans. While soy formula is considered safe by major health organizations, some researchers have raised concerns about excessive manganese exposure in formula-fed infants, particularly given the vulnerability of developing brains. The clinical significance remains debated, but parents might consider cow's milk-based formula as the first choice unless there are specific reasons to use soy formula.

Imaging and Diagnosis Challenges: Unlike many toxicities where blood levels are diagnostic, blood manganese levels don't reliably reflect body burden or brain accumulation. MRI showing characteristic bright signals in basal ganglia is more useful for diagnosing manganese accumulation. This makes monitoring manganese status challenging.

Irreversible Damage: Advanced manganese-induced Parkinsonism causes permanent, irreversible neurological damage. Early-stage toxicity may improve if exposure is stopped, but prolonged exposure leads to lasting disability. Prevention through avoiding excessive exposure is critical, as treatment options are limited.

The Welding Paradox: Many welders are exposed to manganese fumes throughout their careers without developing obvious manganism, while others develop symptoms after relatively shorter exposures. Individual susceptibility varies based on genetic factors, concurrent iron deficiency, liver function, total cumulative exposure, and other variables not fully understood. This variability makes it difficult to establish safe exposure thresholds.

Parkinson's vs. Manganism: While manganism resembles Parkinson's disease, there are important differences. Manganism typically presents with psychiatric symptoms before motor symptoms, affects younger individuals (during working years), responds poorly to levodopa (Parkinson's medication), and shows characteristic MRI changes. Distinguishing between them is important for prognosis and treatment.

Children's Vulnerability: Children's developing nervous systems are particularly vulnerable to manganese. Studies in areas with high environmental manganese have shown cognitive deficits, reduced IQ, attention problems, and behavioral issues in children. These effects can occur at exposure levels that don't cause obvious symptoms in adults.

Most People Don't Need Supplements: It bears repeating that dietary intake of manganese is adequate for the vast majority of people. Supplements are rarely necessary and carry toxicity risks. Unless you have documented deficiency or a specific condition where manganese supplementation is recommended by a healthcare provider, there's no benefit to taking manganese beyond what's in a standard multivitamin (if you take one).

Testing Limitations: There are no good routine tests for manganese status. Blood manganese levels don't correlate well with body stores or toxicity. Clinical assessment based on diet, symptoms, and exposure history is more useful than laboratory testing for most people.

Genetic Factors: Some genetic variations may affect manganese metabolism, transport into the brain, or susceptibility to toxicity. Research in this area is ongoing, but it may explain why some people develop toxicity at lower exposures than others.

Bottom Line

Manganese is an essential trace mineral required for bone formation, antioxidant defense, metabolism, and wound healing. However, unlike most essential nutrients where deficiency is the primary concern, with manganese, toxicity from excessive exposure is a more significant health issue than deficiency.

Manganese deficiency is extremely rare in humans eating varied diets because manganese is widely available in plant-based foods including whole grains (oats, brown rice, whole wheat), legumes (beans, lentils, chickpeas), nuts (pecans, hazelnuts, almonds), seeds, leafy greens, and tea. Most people easily meet the Adequate Intake (2.3 mg for men, 1.8 mg for women) through normal dietary consumption.

The primary health concern with manganese is neurotoxicity leading to manganism, a Parkinson's-like neurological disorder that results from chronic excessive exposure. This primarily occurs from occupational inhalation of manganese dust or fumes (welding, mining) but can also result from excessive supplementation, high-manganese drinking water, or liver disease impairing manganese excretion.

People with liver disease are at dramatically increased risk for manganese accumulation and neurotoxicity because the liver excretes manganese through bile. Anyone with cirrhosis, hepatitis, or any significant liver dysfunction should avoid manganese supplements entirely and may need to limit dietary manganese.

For most healthy people, manganese supplementation is unnecessary. Dietary intake is adequate, and supplements provide no additional benefit while carrying toxicity risks. If you take a multivitamin containing 2-5 mg manganese, this is generally safe for healthy individuals and may provide some bone health support. However, avoid standalone high-dose manganese supplements (over 5 mg) unless specifically prescribed by a healthcare provider for a documented deficiency or condition.

Certain populations should be particularly cautious about manganese: people with liver disease (should avoid supplements completely), welders and workers with occupational manganese exposure (should avoid supplements), individuals with Parkinson's disease or movement disorders (should avoid supplements), infants and young children (developing brains are vulnerable), those taking antipsychotic medications (may increase brain manganese), people with iron deficiency (increased manganese absorption), and anyone living in areas with high manganese in drinking water.

The tolerable upper limit for manganese is 11 mg daily for adults, but given neurotoxicity concerns, staying well below this limit is prudent unless there's a specific medical reason to approach it. Most multivitamins contain 2-5 mg, which is appropriate. Avoid taking multiple supplements containing manganese or high-dose standalone manganese products.

Rich dietary sources of manganese include oats (1 cup dry provides 3.8 mg), pineapple (1 cup provides 2.6 mg), pecans (1 oz provides 1.3 mg), brown rice (1 cup cooked provides 2.1 mg), chickpeas (1 cup cooked provides 1.7 mg), and tea (1 cup provides 0.4-1.3 mg). Emphasizing whole grains over refined grains, including nuts and legumes regularly, and consuming a variety of plant foods easily meets manganese needs without requiring supplementation.

The key message about manganese is this: it's essential but easily obtained from diet; deficiency is extremely rare; toxicity is a real concern, particularly with liver disease or occupational exposure; most people don't need supplements beyond what's in a standard multivitamin; and when in doubt, less is better with manganese—meeting the AI through diet is sufficient, and there's no benefit to higher intakes.

If you're considering manganese supplementation, first assess whether you truly need it (most people don't), ensure you don't have contraindications (particularly liver disease), choose a modest dose (2-5 mg, ideally in a multivitamin rather than standalone), and be alert for any neurological or psychiatric symptoms that could indicate excess.

Keep reading

No posts found